Wolfram Blog
Ed Pegg Jr

The Circles of Descartes

June 16, 2010 — Ed Pegg Jr, Editor, Wolfram Demonstrations Project

Somewhere, you’ve likely been forced to learn how fractions work, and how to calculate 2/7 + 2/5. To some extent, fractions have been falling out of favor in the world, losing out to decimals. The New York Stock Exchange gave up fractions on April 9, 2001.

Much of the time, a decimal is okay. Sometimes, though, especially in mathematics, exact values are desired. Instead of a value being 3.00000000…00727…, it is exactly 3. Or exactly 10/35 + 14/35 = 24/35. For fractions themselves, the Farey sequence is quite interesting—the reduced fractions between 0 and 1 where the denominator is less than or equal to a particular value, like 7. For example, the F7 Farey sequence is the the first row in the following block. The next row has the denominator. The third row is twice the reciprocal of the denominator squared. The fourth row is the denominator from the third row.

Code to generate a table
The F7 Farey sequence and its associated circular bends for Ford Circles

In 1938, Lester Ford tried putting circles with radii equal to that block’s third row above their position on the number line. These are now called Ford circles. All these radii have a one on top. Sometimes, it’s nice to use fractions, but it’s better to use integers when possible, so the bend (or curvature) of a circle is 1/radius, as seen in the fourth row. The circle in the middle of the sequence above with radius 1/8 has a bend of 8. Here is a picture of the Ford circles along with their bends, along with Mathematica code for making it. Notice how the circles all exactly touch some other circles. Each circle is tangent to the neighboring circles. Touching = tangent = kissing, when it comes to circles.

Code to create Ford circles
Ford circles

Suppose you wanted to find the bend of the circle that would fit between 1/6 and 1/5. One method is to square the sum the square roots of the circle bends above it. Here are some examples.

Examples of finding the bend of the circle

Another method is to use the Descartes Circle Theorem. When four circles kiss, or when all four circles touch each other, the bends/curvatures of the circles have an amazing property.

Descartes Circle Theorem

That’s for four circles. A line can be thought of as a circle with a bend of 0, or an infinite radius. When given two circles and a line, the elegant formula below finds the possible third circles. This formula can be tested on the circles above 1/3 and 2/5, and the bends of the two circles they both touch are returned.

This formula finds the possible third circles

Circles don’t have to be in a line, though. Imagine placing circles on the complex plane, the realm of the Mandelbrot set, where (z=x+i y). For the circle with with curvature c1, let z1 be the center point. On the complex plane, when four circles kiss, Mathematica can make use of this expanded Descartes Circle Theorem:

Expanded Descartes Circle Theorem

Here is that theorem in action. All of the given circles are inside the outer circle, which has a negative bend because the others are inside it. If the first few circles have an integer bend, then all the circles, off to infinity, have integers for 1/radius. Here, the circles are colored mod 12, much like the hours on a clock face. In each grouping, only four colors are possible.

The expanded Descartes Circle Theorem in action, colored mod 12

And here is a slight modification of The Circles of Descartes Demonstration, with colors added.

Circles of Descartes

With the values given, it’s easy to test the Descartes Circle Theorem. This isn’t a proof, but it’s always a good idea to test something before attempting to prove it: sometimes you’ll find a counterexample right away, and other times you’ll gain insight.

Counterexample

I’ll close by mentioning Frederick Soddy, who won a Nobel prize for his study of isotopes but is better known for his research on circles and a poem he published in Nature in 1936. Here’s the first verse:

“The Kiss Precise”
by Frederick Soddy

For pairs of lips to kiss maybe
Involves no trigonometry.
‘Tis not so when four circles kiss
Each one the other three.
To bring this off the four must be
As three in one or one in three.
If one in three, beyond a doubt
Each gets three kisses from without.
If three in one, then is that one
Thrice kissed internally.

Posted in: Mathematics
Leave a Comment

6 Comments


Luboš Motl

These are beautiful pictures – the colors are nicely balanced – and weirdly shocking theorems. It’[s good that people would find such things centuries ago – they would probably be less likely to find them today.

Posted by Luboš Motl    June 18, 2010 at 6:09 am
Luboš Motl

By the way, when I download the demonstration/notebook from the URL given above, I don’t see any colors!

Posted by Luboš Motl    June 19, 2010 at 10:12 am
Vidal Aponte

Wow, I find so fascinating that these theorems was found such a long time ago, and it is true how now decimals are used much more than fractions. I also agree that these days people want the decimals or any numbers to be exact value instead of so many zeros at the end of a number.

Posted by Vidal Aponte    June 20, 2010 at 10:27 am
Peter Rowlett

I posted a link to this blog in Carnival of Mathematics #67.

Posted by Peter Rowlett    July 2, 2010 at 5:22 am
Mohamed

this is a very good discussion of such a problem like that

Posted by Mohamed    July 20, 2010 at 5:27 am
sukhraj

This is brilliant, I am trying to do the same on geogebra but I am struggling, what is the code and programme for these?

Posted by sukhraj    January 15, 2014 at 1:22 pm


Leave a comment

Loading...

Or continue as a guest (your comment will be held for moderation):